Most people think a simple blood test for TSH is enough to know if their thyroid is working right. But that’s not always true. I’ve seen too many cases where someone feels exhausted, gains weight, or can’t shake cold sensitivity - and their doctor says, ‘Your TSH is normal.’ Yet their free T4 is low. And they’re left confused, frustrated, and still sick. The truth is, TSH and T4 work together like a thermostat and a heater. One tells you if the system is off. The other tells you why.
What TSH and T4 Actually Measure
TSH stands for thyroid-stimulating hormone. It’s made by your pituitary gland, the control center in your brain. When your thyroid isn’t making enough hormone, the pituitary says, ‘Hey, work harder!’ and pumps out more TSH. That’s why high TSH usually means your thyroid is underperforming - hypothyroidism.
T4, or thyroxine, is the main hormone your thyroid produces. But only a tiny fraction of it is free and active - that’s called free T4 (FT4). The rest is bound to proteins and useless until it’s released. That’s why doctors don’t just measure total T4 anymore. They look at FT4, which tells you how much actual hormone is floating around in your blood, ready to be used by your cells.
Normal TSH ranges are usually 0.5 to 5.0 mIU/L. But that’s a broad average. For pregnant women, the ideal TSH in the first trimester is 0.1 to 2.5 mIU/L. For people over 80, it can safely go up to 6.5 mIU/L without meaning something’s wrong. The same goes for FT4: normal is 0.7 to 1.9 ng/dL, but lab methods vary. Roche’s test might show a value 12% higher than Siemens’ for the same blood sample. That’s why comparing results across labs can lead to unnecessary dose changes.
Why TSH Alone Isn’t Enough
TSH is the most sensitive test for thyroid problems - and that’s why it’s usually the first one ordered. But it’s not perfect. About 5 to 7% of thyroid disorders are missed if you only check TSH. Why? Because sometimes the problem isn’t the thyroid at all. It’s the pituitary. Or the brain. That’s central hypothyroidism. In these rare cases, TSH is low or normal, but T4 is also low. If you don’t check FT4, you’ll miss it entirely.
Another problem is illness. If you’re hospitalized with pneumonia, heart failure, or even severe flu, your body shuts down thyroid hormone production as a survival move. TSH drops, T4 drops - but it’s not a thyroid disease. It’s called non-thyroidal illness syndrome. In the ICU, 30 to 60% of patients show this pattern. Testing only TSH here leads to wrong diagnoses and unnecessary treatment.
Then there’s the ‘normal TSH but symptomatic’ group. A 2023 survey of over 12,000 patients found that 68% waited over a year for a correct diagnosis because their doctor relied only on TSH. On Reddit’s r/Hypothyroidism forum, hundreds of people share stories where their TSH was 3.5-4.5 mIU/L - technically ‘normal’ - but their FT4 was below 0.8 ng/dL. They had hypothyroid symptoms. Their TSH was in the ‘normal’ range, but not in their normal range.
How Doctors Use TSH and T4 Together
Here’s how it works in real practice. First, TSH is checked. If it’s outside 0.5-5.0 mIU/L, then FT4 is automatically tested. That’s the standard two-step protocol used in 95% of cases. If TSH is high and FT4 is low - you have overt hypothyroidism. Treatment starts with levothyroxine, usually at 1.6 mcg per kg of body weight. For a 70kg person, that’s about 112 mcg per day.
If TSH is high but FT4 is normal - that’s subclinical hypothyroidism. It doesn’t always need treatment. But if you’re pregnant, have heart disease, or have symptoms like fatigue and brain fog, most doctors will start medication anyway. For hyperthyroidism, TSH is low (under 0.1 mIU/L) and FT4 is high (over 1.8 ng/dL). That’s Graves’ disease or a toxic nodule. Treatment is different - antithyroid drugs, radioactive iodine, or surgery.
For pregnancy, the rules change. TSH should be kept under 2.5 mIU/L in the first trimester. If it’s not, levothyroxine doses often need to be increased by 25-30% right away. That’s because the baby depends on mom’s thyroid hormone until 12 weeks. Low T4 in early pregnancy is linked to lower IQ scores in children, according to multiple studies.
Dosing Thyroid Medication Right
Levothyroxine isn’t a one-size-fits-all pill. Kids need 10-15 mcg/kg/day. Elderly patients over 70 often start at 0.5-0.7 mcg/kg/day because their hearts can’t handle sudden increases. People with heart disease get even lower starting doses. Dosing is adjusted every 6 weeks based on TSH levels. You don’t rush it. Too much too fast can cause atrial fibrillation or bone loss.
Once stable, TSH is checked once a year. But if you change brands, gain or lose weight, start or stop estrogen, or become pregnant - you need a repeat test. Even switching from one generic to another can cause TSH to shift by 10-15% because of differences in fillers and absorption.
And here’s a big one: most people take levothyroxine on an empty stomach, 30-60 minutes before breakfast. Coffee, calcium, iron, and soy can block absorption. I’ve seen patients take their pill with coffee, then wonder why their TSH keeps creeping up.
What’s New in 2025
The biggest shift coming is the use of FT3 testing. For years, doctors ignored it. But a 2023 trial with 1,200 patients showed that 15-20% of those still feeling tired on levothyroxine had low FT3 - even when TSH and FT4 were normal. This doesn’t mean everyone needs FT3 tested. But if you’ve been on medication for months and still feel off, asking for FT3 might help.
Also, labs are finally getting better at standardizing results. In 2024, the FDA approved a new reference material, NIST SRM 2921. It’s cutting lab-to-lab variation from 15% down to 5%. That means your TSH result from one hospital will match your result from another. No more being told your dose is too high just because the lab changed.
And AI is starting to help. Mayo Clinic’s pilot program used machine learning to combine TSH, FT4, age, BMI, and symptoms. It reduced misdiagnoses by 22%. That’s not replacing doctors - it’s giving them better tools.
What to Ask Your Doctor
If you’re being tested for thyroid issues, ask these questions:
- Are you checking both TSH and free T4?
- What lab are you using, and what’s their normal range?
- If my TSH is normal but I still feel bad, should we check FT4 or FT3?
- Are you adjusting my dose based on symptoms, or just the number?
- Is this result comparable to my last test - same lab, same method?
Don’t let a single number define your health. TSH and T4 are tools. They’re powerful - but only when used right.
Can TSH be normal but still have hypothyroidism?
Yes. This is called subclinical hypothyroidism. TSH is mildly elevated (4.5-10 mIU/L), but free T4 is still in the normal range. Some people have symptoms like fatigue, weight gain, or dry skin. If you’re symptomatic, pregnant, or have heart disease, treatment with levothyroxine is often recommended even if T4 is normal.
Why is free T4 more important than total T4?
Total T4 includes both bound and free hormone. But only free T4 can enter your cells and work. Binding proteins can change due to pregnancy, birth control, liver disease, or kidney problems - making total T4 misleading. Free T4 measures only the active hormone, so it’s a much more accurate indicator of thyroid function.
Can medications affect TSH and T4 test results?
Yes. Estrogen (in birth control or HRT) raises binding proteins, increasing total T4 but not free T4. Lithium, amiodarone, and some antidepressants can lower thyroid hormone production. Iron, calcium, and antacids can block levothyroxine absorption if taken too close to the pill. Always tell your doctor what you’re taking before testing or adjusting doses.
How often should I get my TSH and T4 checked?
When starting or adjusting levothyroxine, check every 6 weeks until stable. Once stable, once a year is enough - unless you’re pregnant, gain/lose weight, start new meds, or feel symptoms returning. Pregnant women need testing every 4-6 weeks in the first half of pregnancy and at least once in the third trimester.
Is it true that some labs give different TSH results?
Yes. Different manufacturers (Roche, Siemens, Abbott) use different methods, and their reference ranges can vary by up to 15%. That’s why switching labs can make your TSH look higher or lower - even if your dose hasn’t changed. Always try to use the same lab for consistency. New FDA standards are reducing this variation, but it’s still a problem.
Write a comment